How to Throw a Sourdough Pizza Party 🍕


Hey Reader!

All summer we've been out here, and I'm beyond grateful that I've had the opportunity to live and work in Muskoka with my family.

But one of the absolute highlights of the entire summer happened yesterday.

We went wake surfing, and it was the first time I'd really seen Juniper ride since she did wake camp earlier this summer. She got up on the wakeboard and was absolutely cruising... and then she went wake surfing and dropped the rope.

If you've never wake surfed before, you start with a rope attached to the boat to get yourself into the wake. Once you're in the right spot, you use your feet and weight to control the board and, eventually, when you're good enough, you can drop the rope and just surf the wave behind the boat.

Well... Juniper is apparently that good now. And she's 8. 😂

I mean... look how damn happy she is. ❤️

I'm not going to lie, I was so proud of her I actually cried a little. 😂 Watching your kid work at something, get better and then finally nail it... yeah, that got me.

She also had Josh and Rhiannon coaching her, and we couldn't have asked for better people to learn from. Rhiannon is competing at the provincial level this season in skiing, which is pretty badass, and seeing her out there coaching Juniper on the wakeboard and wakesurf was just awesome.

We've been working a LOT this summer, so getting a couple of days to slow down, hang by the lake with family and friends, and watch my kid do something like that was pretty special.

Alright... proud dad moment over. 😂

In this week's newsletter, you will find:

  1. A Look Inside My 50 Best Recipes 📊
  2. Pizza Night in Muskoka 🍕
  3. 50% Whole Wheat Sourdough 🌾
  4. Cinnamon Buns from Challah Dough 🤤
  5. This week in Muskoka 🌲

A Look Inside My 50 Best Recipes 📊

Last week I mentioned that I'm bringing back my 50 Best Recipes Excel Workbook for Labour Day weekend at the best price I'll offer.

So this week I thought I'd actually show you what it looks like.

The workbook has 50 of my bakery-tested formulas, but what makes it so useful is the Excel itself. You can scale recipes up or down, adjust hydration and inclusions, calculate DDT and keep your formulas organized all in one place.

I use these spreadsheets in my own baking all the time. In fact, the cinnamon buns in this week's newsletter started with my challah formula—I simply used the Excel to scale up the batch I needed.

If you bought the 50 Best last year, you already have it and don't need to buy it again. If you missed it, join the waitlist below, and I'll let you know when the Labour Day sale goes live.


Pizza Night in Muskoka 🍕

We had a pretty serious pizza party this week, about 20 kids and 10–12 adults—and honestly, making pizza for a crowd all comes down to organization.

My favourite pizza of the night was the 'nduja margherita. Tomato, fresh buffalo mozzarella, 'nduja and basil. Spicy, rich, simple, and so damn good.

I made 24 doughs, using my Excel to scale everything so I knew I'd have enough. The dough, sauce and as many toppings as possible were prepped ahead. I'll cut peppers and prep most vegetables in advance, but things like grated cheese I prefer doing the day of.

And fresh buffalo mozzarella? Right before it goes on the pizza.

The mozzarella I used this weekend was actually made in Italy on Wednesday, arrived at Cheese Boutique in Toronto, made its way up to me in Muskoka and was on a pizza Saturday. Pretty killer.

A few things I've learned cooking pizza for a crowd:

Make more sauce than you think you need.
This week I slow-roasted field tomatoes in the wood oven, peeled them and crushed them by hand with olive oil and salt. That was basically it—and it might have been the best tomato sauce I've made all summer.

Always cook a test pizza.
Do this before everyone is hungry. 😂 It makes sure the oven is properly heated, but more importantly, it forces you to run through your entire setup. Did you forget a cutting board? Pizza cutter? Cooling racks? Something to land the pizza on? You'll find out before you're 15 pizzas deep.

Use smaller pieces of wood to maintain your fire.
Once the oven is hot, I prefer feeding it smaller pieces. A big piece can temporarily drop the temperature and then give you a big spike once it catches. Smaller pieces make it easier to maintain a consistent fire.

Use cooling racks.
When a pizza comes out, I put it straight onto a cooling rack for a minute before cutting it. Air can circulate underneath so the bottom doesn't steam and go soggy, and it gives the cheese and toppings a chance to set. You can always flash the pizza back in the oven before serving if needed.

Get ahead when you're feeding kids.
With 20 kids coming, I wasn't waiting until the party started to fire the first pizza. I cooked two cheese, two pepperoni and two Hawaiian pizzas ahead of time. That gave us six ready to go before the madness started.

Once you're organized, you can stop worrying about everything else and just stretch, top, bake and repeat.

And hopefully eat a slice somewhere in there. 😂


50% Whole Wheat Sourdough 🌾

I baked a batch of my 50% Whole Wheat Sourdough at work this week, partly because I’m trying to mix up my bakes a little and make sure I don’t burn through all my bread flour. Rye, whole wheat, different flour blends... sometimes the practical decisions lead you back to breads you forgot how much you love.

And honestly, this is still one of my favourite everyday loaves.

At 50% whole wheat, you get a ton of flavour and the benefits of more whole grain, but you can still get really nice volume, a soft crumb and a loaf that works for pretty much anything toast, sandwiches, dinner, whatever.

A couple of things to watch if you make it: whole grain flours generally ferment faster, so keep an eye on the dough rather than blindly following the clock. And your hydration may need adjusting depending on the flour you’re using—especially if you’re milling your own grain.

For this formula, I like a warm dough around 27–28°C / 80–82°F, a bulk fermentation of roughly 3 hours, and then an overnight cold proof.

It’s healthy, hearty, full of flavour and just a really good bread to have around.


Cinnamon Buns from Challah Dough 🤤

I made a big batch of cinnamon buns at work this week using my challah dough, and they were a HUGE hit.

I scaled the challah recipe up using my Excel, rolled it out and spread it with soft butter, followed by a 4:1 sugar-to-cinnamon mixture. Rolled it up, sliced it and that was basically it.

The nice thing was we could get everything done the day before. We proofed the cinnamon buns, put them into the fridge overnight and baked them fresh the next morning.

For the glaze, I made a really simple one with icing sugar, vanilla and milk. My assistant Helena also made a cream cheese frosting for them and absolutely crushed it.

This is also a good reminder of just how versatile a solid dough formula can be. I use this challah dough for SO many things. Once you have a dough you understand, you don't always need another recipe—you can start using it as a base and play around with it.

I'll share the challah recipe below if you want to turn your next batch into cinnamon buns.


This week in Muskoka 🌲

Honestly, this week I'm just enjoying my days off whenever I can—swimming, hanging by the lake and soaking up the last few weeks of summer up here.

And if you've been reading about Muskoka all summer and wondering what it's actually like, the new Prime show Sterling Point paints a pretty good picture—at least scenery-wise 😂.

I'll leave you with a plum tart and strawberry tart we made this week because they were both too good not to share.

Alright, it's late (11 pm), and I have to work tomorrow. That's it from Muskoka this week!

Happy Baking,

MJD

Want to learn more from me? Check out my online video resources 👇


Unsubscribe · Preferences

Sourdough Duffy

Join 14,481+ bakers of all experience levels. In this newsletter, you will find recipes, guides, tips and tricks on how you can make bakery-quality bread and master those tricky doughs at home. I'm Matthew, a full-time baking professor and I'm excited to share all that I've learned in my 20 years as a professional chef.

Read more from Sourdough Duffy
a jar of brandied cherries

Hey Reader! Wow, summer is really starting to wind down here in Muskoka. I've been thinking a lot about what an incredible opportunity this summer has been, not only getting to work up here, but having my whole family here with me while I do it. One of the biggest highlights for me as a chef has been how local I've been able to cook. Between our kitchen garden and the incredible produce I get from Eat Local Muskoka, probably over 95% of the produce I'm serving comes from those two places,...

Hey Reader! Wow... somehow I only have three work weeks left in Muskoka. This summer is absolutely flying by. It's also been insanely busy, so a quick apology to anyone who has emailed me and hasn't heard back. I get a lot of emails, and while I'm up here working, I just can't keep up with all of them. I promise I'm not ignoring you! That said, I had a great week. We had the long weekend off, and I got to spend a ton of time with my kids—basically hanging by the lake, swimming, eating and...

Hey Reader! It's 11:10 p.m. as I'm writing this, and the bakery is still going strong. There are baguettes in the oven, a batch of walnut cassis sourdough is resting on the bench, and I'm putting the finishing touches on this week's newsletter before calling it a night. Honestly, I wouldn't have it any other way. It's been a bit of a wild week around here. Juniper has been at wake camp all week and absolutely shredding both wake surfing and wakeboarding. She's been loving every minute of it....